Supreme in West Seattle serves New York–style pizza with an 18-inch, thin, foldable crust and toppings like the recommended double pepperoni.[44] The focus is on large pies meant for sharing, with a straightforward cheese and sauce base that suits classic toppings.[44] Eating this style of pizza, you get the familiar combination of chewy crust, melted cheese, and a bit of crisp at the edge that defines New York slices. A local pizza guide calls out Supreme specifically for its NY-style approach and standout double pepperoni configuration.[44]