The Maine Lobster Roll at Prime Catch is built on a grilled split‑top bun packed with shelled lobster dressed in Old Bay mayonnaise and served with coleslaw as a classic side.[43] What sets this version apart is the focus on whole, generous pieces of lobster and a straightforward seasoning that keeps the shellfish flavor at the center.[43] Each bite layers the buttery toast with cool, lightly seasoned lobster and creamy slaw, giving a rich but balanced feel rather than a heavy sandwich.[43] Diners commenting on the menu tend to single out this roll as a highlight among the restaurant’s seafood offerings, noting that the portion and price place it in the indulgent, special‑occasion category.[31][43]