At the Sack O' Subs outlet near the south end of the island, the Italian Sub features the same mix of Italian meats, provolone, shredded lettuce, tomato, onions, and house dressing on their signature long roll. This branch is known for consistent bread quality and careful assembly, so the fillings are evenly distributed and the roll is fully dressed without being overly messy.[7][20] The texture contrast between the chewy crust and soft interior of the bread makes the meat and cheese stack feel substantial yet easy to eat. Visitors often mention grabbing these subs on the way to the beach or back to rental houses, and the Italian combo is a common choice for feeding a group.[7][1]