Prince Street Pizza serves pepperoni by the slice or as a whole pie, with handcrafted sauce made fresh daily from scratch, creating a bright, tangy base that balances the salty, rendered pepperoni. The slice format allows customers to grab a quick, quality piece without committing to a full pie, and the daily sauce preparation ensures consistency and freshness. The pepperoni sits atop melted cheese and the house-made sauce, with the slice structure designed to hold up under its own weight without grease pooling. The Gaslamp location draws foot traffic from the neighborhood, suggesting reliable execution that keeps regulars returning.